USACE Logo
 
Home > Regulatory Permits > Table of Appeals
Table of Appeals
This is a status list of the appeal actions taken by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Great Lakes and Ohio River Division Regulatory Program, since the appeal process was established in the Federal Register on March 28, 2000.

Table of Appeals

District Appellant Processing # Type of Appeal Date Received Date Completed Decision Final District Action
Detroit Kaine 97-034-007 Permit Denial 8/17/1999 12/20/1999 Has Merit Individual Permit
Buffalo Benderson Development 95-987-1(1) Permit Denial 9/17/1999 4/7/2000 Has Merit Permit Denial
Detroit Alexander et. al. 98-016-159 Permit Denial 10/15/1999 4/13/2000 No Merit Not applicable
Detroit Made in Detroit, Inc. 88-007-079-4 Permit Denial 10/29/1999 3/28/2000 Has Merit Permit Denial
Detroit Leaver 91-010-007-1 Permit Denial 11/19/1999 4/28/2000 No Merit Not applicable
Buffalo Guidone 199900489 Jurisdictional Determination 12/30/1999 3/8/2000 No Merit Not applicable
Detroit Evangelista 00-010-030 Jurisdictional Determination 5/25/2000 8/25/2000 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Detroit Venier 99-006-015 Proffered Permit 8/24/2000 11/6/2000 Withdrawn Not applicable
Detroit Bayberry Companies 88-245-003-5 Permit Denial 9/5/2000 12/4/2000 Has Merit Permit Denial
Detroit Ashbaugh 99-012-004 Proffered Permit 10/5/2000 1/4/2001 Has Merit Modified Proffered Permit
Detroit Carabell 99-250-002-1 Permit Denial 12/4/2000 3/5/2001 No Merit Not applicable
Detroit Allen 99-016-320 Proffered Permit 12/13/2000 6/29/2001 Has Merit NWP 14 Verified
Chicago Northbrook Sports Club 200100288 Jurisdictional Determination 4/27/2001 7/26/2001 No Merit Not applicable
Detroit Bayha 00-034-005 Jurisdictional Determination 4/30/2001 5/22/2001 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Louisville City of Evansville 199901250 Permit Denial 5/8/2001 8/29/2001 No Merit Not applicable
Buffalo NEC Transit/Wm. LLC 200000325(2) Jurisdictional Determination 6/1/2001 8/30/2001 No Merit Not applicable
Chicago Laycom 200100426 Jurisdictional Determination 8/16/2001 11/28/2001 No Merit Not applicable
Chicago PAL Group 200100602 Jurisdictional Determination 9/6/2001 2/5/2002 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Chicago Northbrook Pointe 200100391 Jurisdictional Determination 9/17/2001 3/29/2002 Has Merit No Jurisdiction
Louisville Bullitt Farm 200100892 Jurisdictional Determination 9/17/2001 8/23/2002 No Merit Not Applicable
Louisville Escue/Beard 200100524 Jurisdictional Determination 9/26/2001 12/28/2001 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Louisville Curtis 200101268 Jurisdictional Determination 11/23/2001 9/3/2002 No Merit Not Applicable
Chicago Lundstrom 200101163 Jurisdictional Determination 11/30/2001 10/4/2002 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Chicago Village of Hoffman Estates 200101161 Jurisdictional Determination 12/12/2001 1/10/2002 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Louisville Mahoning Valley Camp 200001336 Initial Proffered Permit 5/13/2002 7/18/2002 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Chicago Village of Tinley Park 200200187 Jurisdictional Determination 5/17/2002 1/27/2003 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Chicago Muetze 199800898 Jurisdictional Determination 5/22/2002 9/4/2002 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Detroit Suedkamp 97-016-525-1 Permit Denial 5/28/2002 7/18/2002 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Chicago Amli Commercial Properties 200000568 Jurisdictional Determination 6/12/2002 11/22/2005 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Louisville Wal Mart Corp. 200200675 Jurisdictional Determination 6/26/2002 8/27/2002 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Chicago Continental 127 Fund LLC 200200333 Jurisdictional Determination 7/25/2002 11/8/2002 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Detroit Suedkamp 97-016-525-1 Permit Denial 8/16/2002 11/15/2002 No Merit Not Applicable
Detroit McAulay 02-016-152 Jurisdictional Determination 8/16/2002 1/27/2003 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Detroit Mead 02-016-119 Jurisdictional Determination 8/26/2002 1/9/2003 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Detroit Martin Oil 02-145-028 Jurisdictional Determination 9/12/2002 5/1/2003 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo Pyramid Companies 200200909 Jurisdictional Determination 9/23/2002 10/16/2003 No Merit Not Applicable
Louisville Mahoning Valley Camp 200001336 Jurisdictional Determination 9/24/2002 4/12/2004 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Detroit Viele 01-016-305 Jurisdictional Determination 10/7/2002 1/9/2003 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Louisville Coxco Realty 200000935 Jurisdictional Determination 10/17/2002 4/30/2003 Has Merit Modified Jurisdiction
Louisville Taylor 200100771 Jurisdictional Determination 1/22/2003 10/15/2003 No Merit Not Applicable
Louisville Paducah McCracken JSA 200201472 Jurisdictional Determination 3/3/2003 3/2/2006 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Detroit MI Peat Co. 92-276-002-2 Initial Proffered Permit 5/8/2003 1/28/2005 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Louisville Bankview Farm 199901014 Jurisdictional Determination 5/20/2003 11/13/2007 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Detroit Village Building Co. Inc. 01-010-078-0 Jurisdictional Determination 5/28/2003 7/8/2004 No Merit Not Applicable
Chicago Dawson 200200663 Jurisdictional Determination 6/23/2003 3/17/2005 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Detroit Lozon Land & Lake Realty 81-011-026-3 Jurisdictional Determination 7/2/2003 8/8/2005 No Merit Not Applicable
Detroit Elk Rapids Preserve 99-056-141-0 Jurisdictional Determination 7/21/2003 4/2/2004 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Detroit Pittman 01-016-303-2 Permit Denial 8/4/2003 8/20/2004 Has Merit Individual Permit
Chicago Whitney 200300298 Jurisdictional Determination 10/7/2003 3/17/2005 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Chicago Omidfar 200300721 Jurisdictional Determination 11/13/2003 5/21/2004 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Detroit The Sand Point Toy Box, LLC 02-216-069-0 Permit Denial 1/14/2004 8/10/2005 Has Merit Individual Permit
Chicago Dayfield Properties, LLC 200400050 Jurisdictional Determination 2/12/2004 8/25/2005 Has Merit No Jurisdiction
Detroit City of Gary 90-145-129-2 Jurisdictional Determination 2/17/2004 12/7/2004 Has Merit No Jurisdiction
Detroit Leicht, Gene 03-164-038-0 Jurisdictional Determination 4/8/2004 8/16/2004 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo Sylvester Material Company 98-387-0028(1) Jurisdictional Determination 4/14/2004 8/31/2004 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Chicago Dan Klaus 200400294 Jurisdictional Determination 5/13/2004 8/1/2005 No Merit Not Applicable
Buffalo RB-3 2004-01413 Jurisdictional Determination 8/24/2004 7/28/05 No Merit Not Applicable
Detroit Don Richards 02-157-021-0 Proffered Permit 8/25/2004 9/15/2005 No Merit Not Applicable
Detroit Cherry Tree Inn 00-056-124-1 Proffered Permit 8/27/2004 4/15/2005 No Merit Not applicable
Chicago City of Hickory Hills 200400798 Jurisdictional Determination 9/3/2004 9/6/2005 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Detroit Capa Bran Estates 02-056-089-0 Jurisdictional Determination 10/18/2004 11/8/2004 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Chicago Skirp Construction 200400993 Jurisdictional Determination 11/12/2004 10/13/2005 Has Merit No Jurisdiction
Buffalo Tyler-SOM Properties 2004-01332(0) Jurisdictional Determination 12/14/2004 5/26/2005 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Chicago Barrington 200400503 Jurisdictional Determination 12/23/2004 10/31/2007 Has Merit
Pittsburgh Rucci 200401817 Jurisdictional Determination 1/12/2005 11/13/07 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Chicago CenterPoint Properties 200301082 Jurisdictional Determination 1/14/2005 10/6/2005 Has Merit Modified Jurisdiction
Buffalo Brannon Homes 2004-00912(0) Jurisdictional Determination 1/20/2005 1/31/2006 No Merit Not Applicable
Detroit Bay City Shoreline six files Permit Denial 2/2/2005 12/29/05 Has Merit Permit Denial
Buffalo Schantz Homes 2004-00875 Jurisdictional Determination 2/10/2005 08/23/06 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo Wal-Mart 2004-01997(0) Jurisdictional Determination 2/17/2005 3/31/2005 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Chicago Doctor East 200500173 Jurisdictional Determination 2/24/2005 10/31/2007 Has Merit Issued Permit with Preliminary Jurisdictional Determination
Louisville Wayne Johnson 200500000 Jurisdictional Determination 3/8/2005 11/13/2007 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Chicago Ingalls Farm 200500145 Jurisdictional Determination 3/14/2005 7/19/2005 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo Greenfield Homes 2003-01972(1) Jurisdictional Determination 3/15/2005 12/29/2005 No Merit Not Applicable
Buffalo JF Development 2002-02310(1) Permit Denial 4/19/2005 10/13/05 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo NYS Canal Corp 2004-01156(0) Proffered Permit 5/12/2005 12/29/05 Has Merit Modified Proffered Permit
Buffalo Buffalo-Lancaster Airport 2004-01811(3) Preliminary Jurisdicitional Determination 8/22/2005 9/19/2005 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Chicago Schroeder Material, Inc. 200500049 Jurisdictional Determination 11/30/2005 02/28/06 Has Merit Pending
Buffalo Clayton Meyers 200500609 Jurisdictional Determination 12/5/2005 10/3/2007 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Louisville Mike Eaton 200501530 Jurisdictional Determination 12/28/2005 11/13/2007 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Chicago Ridge Logistics 2006-23420 Jurisdictional Determination 1/5/2007 2/14/2007 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Buffalo Donald Clark 2003-01138 Jurisdictional Determination 1/17/2006 2/24/2006 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Buffalo Shelby Crushed Stone 2006-00616 Jurisdictional Determination 3/27/2006 6/14/2006 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Louisville Jackson County Water Association 200400646 Permit Denial 4/6/2006 12/4/2007 No Merit Not Applicable
Detroit Lucky 7 Development LLC 91-012-048-4 Jurisdictional Determination 5/30/2006 12/1/2006 No Merit Not Applicable
Buffalo Alice McCauslin 2006-01122(0) Jurisdictional Determination 8/18/2006 5/3/2007 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Buffalo Breezethrough Inc. 2004-00951(1) Preliminary Jurisdicitional Determination 8/29/2006 9/28/2006 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Buffalo Breezethrough Inc. 2004-00951(1) Jurisdictional Determination 10/6/2006 2/14/2007 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo Cuyahoga County 200601023(0) Jurisdictional Determination 10/6/2006 1/19/2007 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Chicago Gary Rink 2006818 Jurisdictional Determination 10/13/2006 10/31/2007 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Detroit Greg Schmidt 900350463 Permit Denial 10/16/2006 10/24/2007 Has Merit Permit Denial
Detroit Stanley Schaeffer 31760210 Proffered Permit 12/22/2006 10/27/2008 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo Ballantyne Development 200300734(0) Jurisdictional Determination 12/26/2006 3/5/2007 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Detroit Tawas Beach Club 98-016-160-4 Permit Denial 1/12/2007 7/29/08 Has Merit Permit Denial
Chicago Warmke Parcel 2006-14112 Jurisdictional Determination 1/12/2007 10/31/2007 Has Merit
Buffalo Dennis Cerny 1997-5120016(8) Jurisdictional Determination 3/9/2007 11/13/2007 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Buffalo Omni Pride One 2005-1546(2) Jurisdictional Determination 3/27/2007 11/13/2007 Has Merit

Maintained Jurisdiction

Detroit Devlon Properties 02-041-011-0 Permit Denial 4/21/2007 8/10/2009 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo Ohio Department of Natural Resources 1996-4790013(11) Permit Denial 6/5/2007 1/22/2010 No Merit Not Applicable
Chicago Hoffman Estates 2007-145 Jurisdictional Determination 6/22/2007 11/13/2007 Has Merit
Chicago Ridge Logistics 2006-23420 Jurisdictional Determination 7/20/2007 11/13/2007 Has Merit No Jurisdiction
Buffalo Diamond Hawk 2006-1930 Jurisdictional Determination 10/22/2007 2/29/2008 No Merit Not Applicable
Buffalo Jonathan Hayek 2007-501 Jurisdictional Determination 10/29/2007 9/2/2008 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Detroit Walter Helmke 2007-1187-176 Jurisdictional Determination 11/13/2007 5/29/2008 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Buffalo Dennis Boos - Inland Marina 2007-1633 Jurisdictional Determination 5/2/2008 7/2/2009 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Buffalo Jeffrey Spicer 2006-138 Jurisdictional Determination 5/30/2008 7/2/2009 No Merit Not Applicable
Detroit Gordon Colorito 2007-1512-16 Proffered Permit 11/3/2008 12/18/2009 No Merit Not Applicable
Detroit D'Anne Wilson 2007-1563-16 Proffered Permit 1/26/2009 11/13/2009 No Merit Not Applicable
Louisville Kentucky Transportation 2008-402 Jurisdictional Determination 2/9/2009 4/9/2009 Withdrawn Not Applicable
Buffalo Trinity Baptist Church 2008-00834 Jurisdictional Determination 2/12/2009 2/5/2010 Has Merit Modified Jurisdiction
Detroit Star Financial 2003-1020251 Jurisdictional Determination 4/13/2009 3/31/2010 Has Merit Modified Jurisdiction
Chicago LM Commercial Properties 2008-34 Jurisdictional Determination 4/15/2009 6/1/2009 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Louisville Coxco Realty, LLC 2000-935 Proffered Permit 4/27/2009 12/15/2009 Has Merit

Modified Proffered Permit

Chicago David Castle 2009-00023 Jurisdictional Determination 5/4/2009 5/20/2009 Not Accepted

Not Applicable

Pittsburgh United Refractories 2009-283 Jurisdictional Determination 5/18/2009 6/18/2009 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Chicago Lily Pond Stone/Hanna Farm 2009-00023 Jurisdictional Determination 6/17/2009 4/16/2010 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Huntington T&R Properties 57595 Jurisdictional Determination 8/13/2009 7/30/2010 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Chicago Knanaya Catholic Society 2009-233 Jurisdictional Determination 11/16/2009 11/16/2010 Has Merit Modified Jurisdiction
Chicago Virginia Ferrell 2008-477 Jurisdictional Determination 12/11/2009 1/4/2010 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Detroit Ivan & Clara Todd 2004-470040 Proffered Permit 3/12/2010 2/25/2011 No Merit Not Applicable
Buffalo Trinity Baptist Church 2008-834 Jurisdictional Determination 8/13/2010 9/21/2010 Not Accepted

Not Applicable

Louisville Scott County Fiscal Court 2003-4 Permit Denial 8/30/2010 3/23/2011 Has Merit

Not Applicable (Withdrawn)

Huntington Holsinger, Delbert 2010-628 Jurisdictional Determination 1/24/2011 2/25/2011 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Chicago Gallagher & Henry, Warmke Parcel 2006-14112 Jurisdictional Determination 1/25/2011 6/21/2011 No Merit Not Applicable
Louisville Steve Keiler 2010-0695 Jurisdictional Determination 4/7/2011 5/2/2011 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Buffalo Mohawk Valley EDGE 2001-890 Proffered Permit 6/13/2011 8/31/2011 Has Merit Pending
Huntington Edward Slattery 2011-112 Jurisdictional Determination 7/13/2011 10/4/2011 Has Merit Maintained Jurisdiction
Buffalo Harvest Presbyterian Church 1999-00190 Jurisdictional Determination 7/28/2011 10/24/2011 Has Merit Pending
Detroit Verlin Marsee 2009-00045-7 Permit Denial 8/23/2011 11/16/2011 No Merit Not Applicable
Chicago Moraine Valley Community College 2011-00306 Jurisdictional Determination 10/7/2011 11/17/2011 Not Accepted Not Applicable
Buffalo Dean Van Dress 2010-01402 Jurisdictional Determination 12/5/2011 Pending Pending  

For information regarding an appeal, contact:

Appeals Review Officer

(513) 684-6212